How the Hero's Journey Became the Guiding Force in Disney Animation

How the Hero's Journey Became the Guiding Force in Disney Animation

How the Hero's Journey Became the Guiding Force in Disney Animation

Brian Smith
Brian Smith
3 years ago

Many of you are likely aware of the book, The Writer’s Journey by Christopher Vogler. You might also be aware that it’s based on the writings of Joseph Campbell and it applies Campbell’s ideas on the Hero’s Journey to cinema in general and screenwriting specifically. Many of you may have even read Vogler’s book or Cambell’s writings, or both. But did you know that The Writer’s Journey started as an internal memo at Walt Disney Animation Studios while developing The Little Mermaid and Beauty and the Beast? It was meant as a guide for developing their stories into feature films, becoming required reading for Disney Feature’s creative executives, and was essentially their gospel for creating stories over the ensuing decade. The echoes of those principles ring just as loudly and clearly today across not only Disney but the entire animation storytelling landscape.

If you saw Alec Sokolow’s recent Stage 32 webinar on the Hero’s Journey, you would have learned that the journey is primarily about getting the character from one place to another, but not how you might initially think. Yes, in many movies, the character is going from one physical space to another, but the Hero’s Journey is most effective when it is an inner journey for the Hero. Whether that journey is taking the hero on an emotional journey or a journey of self-discovery, the most interesting Hero’s Journeys are the ones that change the character profoundly and noticeably.

Alec used his own experience in writing Toy Story (which netted him an Oscar nomination) as how that notion was effectively conveyed. Yes, both Woody and Buzz go on a physical journey in which they leave the Ordinary World of Andy’s bedroom and enter the Special World outside the house, including Pizza Planet and Syd’s house. In those places, they experience the stages of Tests, Allies and Enemies, The Approach, and The Supreme Ordeal. But in the second act, those stages do more than just advance the story. They also develop Woody and Buzz as characters, motivating each of them to grow and change by the end in a way that was satisfying to the audience. For more on how Alec specifically applied the Hero's Journey to Toy Story and other successful films, be sure to check out his webinar.

How the Heros Journey Became the Guiding Force in Disney Animation

Anyone interested in writing and storytelling, be it live-action or animation, has been inundated with the idea of 3-act structure, where your first act is 25-30 pages, your second act is 50-60 pages, and your third act is 25-30 pages. The first act represents the exposition, the second act represents the conflict, and the third act represents the resolution. That’s can feel like a daunting number of pages and a rigid structure in which to fit your story. Sokolow even said in his webinar that he often struggles with the second act because it’s so long and so much has to happen.

But, if you were to think of your story in the 12 stages of the Hero’s Journey rather than in three full acts, it becomes more palatable, especially when you put the stages of the journey alongside where they go inside of the 3-act structure. This is especially true when writing an animated story that needs to be followed by audiences of all ages.

Using the Christopher Vogler version of the Hero's Journey from his book, The Writer’s Journey, it looks as follows:

Act 1

Ordinary World
Call to Adventure
Refusal
Meeting the Mentor
Crossing the First Threshold

Act 2

Tests, Allies, and Enemies
Approach
Supreme Ordeal
Reward

Act 3

The Road Back
Resurrection
Return with the Elixir

Now, let's see how we can apply these steps to an animated story...

How the Heros Journey Became the Guiding Force in Disney Animation

Whenever I’m writing anything, I always start by using those stages as an outline. To borrow a phrase from animation, think of it as keyframing. Each of the steps in the Hero’s Journey is a keyframe, and then once you have those, all you need to do is the in-betweening, filling out the details that get you from one stage of the journey to the next. This way, the structure doesn’t seem so rigid, and the amount of writing is less daunting. In fact, the structure is assisting you in developing a cohesive and coherent story.

When I was studying animation at USC, one of my instructors had been a character animator and storyboard artist at Walt Disney Animation Studios, and he told us a story about the development of Beauty and the Beast. They were struggling with the story until Jeffrey Katzenberg told them they were approaching it from the wrong direction. The story team was developing the story from Belle’s point of view, and Katzenberg told them that it was the Beast’s point of view that was driving the story. It was the Beast who was the one who needed to change. He needed to go from “spoiled, selfish, and unkind” to someone who had “learned to love and could be loved in return.”

Beauty and the Beast is a story that does so many things well in creating drama. It gives us a character with a clear need who will struggle to meet that need because he starts out the story unwilling to change. It gives us a ticking clock for when that need must be met in the form of the petals falling from the rose. And it gives us a clear consequence if the need isn’t met in that he will remain a beast forever. The Hero’s Journey plays an integral role in progressing the story and in organically bringing about change in the Beast.

Act 1

Ordinary World – The Beast lives alone in an enchanted castle.
Call to Adventure – Maurice arrives seeking help.
Refusal – The Beast locks him in the tower.
Meeting the Mentor – Belle arrives searching for Maurice.
Crossing the First Threshold – Belle takes Maurice’s place as the Beast’s prisoner.

Act 2

Tests, Allies, and Enemies – The Beast tells Belle she can go anywhere she wants except the West Wing; Belle refuses to eat dinner with him; he tells the servants that if she doesn’t eat with him, she doesn’t eat at all; the magic mirror shows him an image of Belle telling one of the enchanted servants that she doesn’t want anything to do with him.
Approach – Belle wanders into the West Wing. The Beast catches her there and flies into a rage, causing Belle to run away and leave the castle.
Supreme Ordeal – Belle is attacked by wolves, and the Beast rescues her but is injured, and Belle uses her horse to carry him back to the castle.
Reward – Belle nurses the Beast back to health; the Beast shows Belle (a book lover) his massive library; they start to eat together. Belle says she’s happy, but she wishes she could see her father again.

Act 3

The Road Back – The Beast shows Belle the magic mirror that shows Maurice searching for Belle in the woods, sick and possibly dying. The Beast, now able to love, allows Belle to go to him. She takes Maurice home, but the jealous Gaston finds out about the Beast and rallies the villagers to go kill him.
Resurrection – The villagers attack the castle. The Beast won’t fight, but the enchanted servants repel the attack. Only Gaston gets to the Beast’s lair and is about to kill him until the Beast sees Belle has returned. He fights off Gaston, and it seems as though Belle and the Beast will be reunited until Gaston stabs the Beast before falling to his death. Belle professes her love for the Beast as he draws his last breath and the last petal falls from the rose. Having learned to love and earned the love of another, the Beast is resurrected and transforms back into a human.
Return with the Elixir – Belle and the (now human) Beast dance in the ballroom, seemingly to live happily ever after.

It's clear in Beauty and the Beast that the Hero’s Journey not only moved the story forward but it motivated the change that the Beast had to go through. That’s one of the many things that the Hero’s Journey does for the writer. It allows for the story progression and character development to happen in tandem with each other. All of the pieces work together to create a dramatic arc that makes this film so successful.

How the Heros Journey Became the Guiding Force in Disney Animation

That is one of the reasons that the Hero’s Journey works so well in animated features. The best-animated features are about characters and how those characters need to change. Whether it’s the Beast needing to learn to love; Hiccup (How to Train Your Dragon) needing to prove to himself that brains are as important as brawn; or whether it’s about Mirabel needing to find value in what makes her different (Encanto); or it’s about Woody and Buzz accepting that their places in the world are not what they thought they were (Toy Story); or whether it’s Rick accepting his daughter for who she is (The Mitchells vs. The Machines), animation is at its best when its heroes are flawed characters who learn and grow. The Hero’s Journey is the best way to make that happen.

Do you have a favorite example of how the Hero’s Journey worked in an animated feature? I would love it if you shared it in the comments below!

Got an idea for a post? Or have you collaborated with Stage 32 members to create a project? We'd love to hear about it. Email Emily at emily@stage32.com and let's get your post published!

Please help support your fellow Stage 32ers by sharing this on social. Check out the social media buttons at the top to share on Instagram @stage32, Twitter @stage32, Facebook @stage32, and LinkedIn @stage-32.

Get engaged
13

About the Author

Brian Smith

Brian Smith

Production Manager, Screenwriter, Script Consultant

Brian has been a professional screenplay reader since 2006, and has written coverage for over 1,000 scripts and books for companies such as Walden Media and Scott Free Films. Scripts and books that Brian has read and covered include Twilight, Touristas, Nim’s Island, Hotel for Dogs, and Inkheart. Br...

Want to share your Story on the Stage 32 Blog?
Get in touch

13 Comments on Brian's Article

Laurie Ashbourne
Screenwriter, Producer, Author
I had posted this in the writers' room awhile back; it's a letter from screenwriter Linda Wolverton on B&B helping the brass understand how to maintain the core/theme of the story. It's so easy for these things to become derailed. This also resulted in the prologue that exists in the final film. https://www.stage32.com/profile/39177/photos#3090711816238540116
3 years ago
Maurice Vaughan
Screenwriter
I remember you posted about that letter in the Writers' Room, Laurie. I thought about it as I read this blog.
3 years ago
Laurie Ashbourne
Screenwriter, Producer, Author
As an aside, B&B's Academy nomination for best picture, changed the landscape for the Academy awards and ushered in the highly competive animation category we have today. So it's worth a study for all filmmakers. Angela Landsbury introduced its opening prologue as "perhaps the best segue ever on screen." She died today but her contribution to this film will live on forever.
3 years ago
Maurice Vaughan
Screenwriter
Great blog, Brian. I took Alec Sokolow’s webinar about The Hero’s Journey. I’m trying to learn more and more about The Hero’s Journey so I can use it better in my scripts. Thanks for writing the 12 steps in the blog for us to copy, paste, and use.
3 years ago
Eyo Obot
Animator
Good article Mr. Brian Thank you I highly benefitted from it
3 years ago
Brywn Philips
Screenwriter
Thank you Brian, your article was very helpful and engaging. I've enjoyed reading everyone's comments too. I would also recommend The Virgin's Promise by Kim Hudson which is a deeper dive into the internal path of the protagonist/hero.
3 years ago
Brian Smith
Production Manager, Screenwriter, Script Consultant
Thanks for the recommendation, Brywn! I will be sure to check that one out!
3 years ago
Excellent article, except that the concept of the Hero's Journey had existed centuries before Disney noticed it and made it company policy for his screenwriters (in fact, it was present in many of the Grimms Brothers and Charles Perrault fairy tales on which many of the Disney films were based) -- the whole concept actually goes back to ancient Greek and Viking mythology (e.g. Jason and the Argonauts, Lord of the Rings, etc.) and has therefore been in use for several thousand years!
3 years ago
Immanuel Solas
Producer, Marketing/PR, Director
Nice article :) I worked 7 years at the Joseph Campbell Foundation and 3.5 years at Michael Wiese Press, publisher of Vogler's book. The formula is good, but not a substitute for moving intentionally through your own Hero's Journey of transformation — which will only make your writing better because you're the actual instrument of creativity. The HJ is first and foremost a structure for approaching life that calls you to be it before you can authentically write it.
3 years ago
Brian Smith
Production Manager, Screenwriter, Script Consultant
That's absolutely true. I was a TA for Chris Vogler when he taught a class at USC based on the HJ, and the first day he said that this went beyond storytelling and was a philosophy on how to live your life.
3 years ago
Pamela Van Amstel
Filmmaker, Screenwriter
Indeed I suggest what you have and it's in the title, two characters as dual protagonists. Beauty & The Beast. They both have a hero's journey. Also, it's not just the protagonist that has a hero's journey. HJ's happen with minor characters. It's not just the protagonist that experiences the journey, although they do evolve on a larger arch. In my recent animation feature script, SHY GUY: Bobcat born to be wild, there are two parallel stories with dual protagonists. The main protagonist has a larger arch, in fact, it is a rite of passage where Shiloh the bobcat goes from a kitten to an adult. The other protagonist Roz the Aussie maverick keeper who kidnaps him and takes him back to the wild undergoes her own personal journey of discovery of self. The area I chose to develop was the notion of an episodic plot, where Shiloh grows up and lives through the 4 seasons, displaying the microcosm of the wilderness. It is an epic adventure genre, going through the twelve steps of the Hero's Journey. Act 1, kitten. Act two part 1. teenager. Act 2 part 2, maturing adult. Act three adult. The flaws in the character development from when he had been rescued after being left as roadkill, rehabilitated, but through fate, exposed to habituation encountering the institutionalized residents of the sanctuary. He is then kidnapped and with his human foibles, struggles to live back in the wild. By the midpoint, he overcomes his first obstacle, but he is still not fully wild. With the help of his mentor Ruby, a mother bobcat, he uses both his budding wildness and human flaws to help his tribe overcome adversity as the exploitation of man and environmental disaster encroach the forest, which helps him become fully wild.
3 years ago
Brian Smith
Production Manager, Screenwriter, Script Consultant
That sounds like a very cool story, Pamela! Best of luck with it!
3 years ago
Rona Edwards
Author, Filmmaker, Producer, Screenwriter, Script Consultant, Singer, Stage Director, Transmedia Producer, Actor, Voice Artist, Voice Actor
Hi Brian- you are approaching this as if The Beast is the protagonist. When Belle is the Protagonist. The ordinary world we see is Belle’s world. It is Belle who we follow. Gaston becomes a threat/antagonist but as with all love stories the beast changes from antagonist to ally and romantic partner- but it is Belle who tames the beast and also saves him, his castle from the curse and Gaston (with the help of the Beast and the household staff under the course). She is the one who rights the world and puts it back in order albeit changed from whence she came for the better.
3 years ago
Rona Edwards
Author, Filmmaker, Producer, Screenwriter, Script Consultant, Singer, Stage Director, Transmedia Producer, Actor, Voice Artist, Voice Actor
Belle changes too.  In fact I would argue that that a number of characters can have a hero’s journey albeit sometimes an anti-hero’s journey in one movie. Their desires clash possibly. . If you look at Silence of the Lambs for example, Clarice is the protagonist. Buffalo Bill is the antagonist and Hannibal Lector a dark mentor.  Each has their own albeit very different  journey that would fit into Chris’ and Campbell’s structure. Everyone one has a journey with different outcomes.  The antagonist or villain needs to be stopped.  But here are two characters that have succeeded in their own journey and one who didn’t succeed.  Clarice graduates and Lector is on his way to having dinner with an old friend. Lector hasn’t changed that much though one could argue he’s  just gotten even more cagier. Clarice is smarter but she’ll always be hearing the lambs screaming maybe even louder now than before.  They  return to the ordinary world with an elixir - a reward - new knowledge  about themselves, each other and the world which will really mean, they can never return to the world that was with this new found knowledge.  Things have changed because of their experience and journey. Nothing can bring back the hour of the splendor in the grass….  With Beauty and the Beast, Belle changes, too. Her objective is to save her father and for that she sacrifices herself. It has consequences. It changes everything  for her. She wants to escape but through her journey,  she learns you can’t judge a book by its cover.  You have to give people a chance. She widens her world view. She grows up!  And becomes a fervent defender of the Beast.  And of course there’s the “true love” element.  The Beast has his journey as does Gaston.  They all collide. But it is Belle who rises up to the occasion. And teaches the Beast something and he in turn teaches her as well.  Gaston- typical villain - gets his comeuppance.   All characters have clear wants and objectives. 
3 years ago
Laurie Ashbourne
Screenwriter, Producer, Author
Yes. As the screenwriter indicates in the letter I posted in my comment; this is Belle's story.
3 years ago
John F Tupper
Screenwriter, 3D Animator, Art Director
Thanks, Brian, for reminding me how much I love crafting a story, even though it sometimes means lots of pacing and banging my head on a wall. It also reminds me that even though a story might have won a bunch of awards there's always room to make the characters and their journeys better. As for a favourite animated film, among many, I still love Brad Bird's "Ratatouille." Remy, Linguini and all check all the story progression boxes in a fun and brilliantly animated way. John Tupper, 3D animator and screenwriter in Silicon Valley
3 years ago
John F Tupper
Screenwriter, 3D Animator, Art Director
Love it!
3 years ago
John F Tupper
Screenwriter, 3D Animator, Art Director
Extremely helpful.
3 years ago
Komal Bhadana
3D Animator
Wow, such a helpfull and great article. Thank you so much Brian for this information.
3 years ago
Shellie Schmals
Actor, Film Festival Director, Host/Presenter
Brian, thank you for sharing all this information!!! Especially with the Disney examples :) For anyone who is new to animation, this is a fabulous breakdown. My new favorite heroes journey ... Elsa from "Frozen"; my classic, Raggedy Ann in "Raggedy Ann & Andy - A Musical Adventure" -which also was the scariest!
3 years ago
13