As you know, dialogue is one of the fundamental attributes of a story. If you want your film, television show, or novel to be believable, dramatic, and memorable it must have good professional dialog. But what exactly is that?
Novelist Ayn Rand in one of her letters gave important tips about dialogue to a budding fiction writer. Following is an excerpt from Rand’s 1944 letter to (renowned investor) Gerald Loeb. Loeb had sent Rand drafts of one of his short stories and raised the topic of his dialogue. Rand’s reply to Loeb included the following passage:
“…the problem of a dialogue writer is a subtle one: he must make his dialogue sound as if this is the way people really talk—and yet write it with a brevity, clarity and economy of words never achieved by anybody in real-life talk. He must never allow an extra line which has no specific purpose. He must have every line carry either exposition or characterization—and usually both. But he cannot allow his characters to talk so precisely that they will sound stilted. The trick is to select out of people’s normal expressions those lines that are representative, that can give you—in one flash—the whole idea of the person or subject discussed, while sounding completely natural. It is a very difficult trick—and I was surprised to see how well you’ve done it.
“I can clarify this best on the example of your own dialogue. Take your first line. When Tom enters, Olivia says: “Well, I never.” That is all—and it’s perfect for its purpose. It shows surprise, and rudeness, and a woman who talks in bromides. In real life, she would have said that and a great deal more. But you omitted the “more”; that line was enough, it said everything, yet was natural. You could have selected another popular bromide—but most of them would have been meaningless—you picked the one that was characteristic. This is true of all your dialogue in the scene. All of it is the natural expression of a person and suggests a lot beyond the actual words used. “Come over now and sit on the bed and watch me dress but be a good boy”—is a swell line. It gives you the complete picture of a sloppy little tart without taste or manners.” (1)
Excellent advice about writing dialogue. How can writers apply this insight of Rand’s?
First, look for representative and suggestive expressions in the dialog of your own characters. That is, when you are editing your story check if your characters are using distinctive essential expressions that reveal them and make them real. If yes, well done. If not, at least you are now aware of this lack and know what to fix. That is always a good first step to learning a needed skill.
A good second step is to look for these types of expressions in well written novels and films. Study these examples, think about them, see their value and effect.
Continue reading
https://mailchi.mp/c81b130f94d8/hello-from-scott-8847901?e=074b8b7794
1 person likes this
Ayn Rand giving advice on writing dialogue?
2 people like this
What is 'professional dialog' and how does it differ from amateur dialog?
1 person likes this
Some of the best dialogue writers like Tarantino, Allen have full chunks of it from some life anecdotes, many pro actors ad lib, I've read of adaptation writers saying they've got large portions of the dialogue copy/pasted verbatim from the source materials, books, articles....everyone does his best under the circumstances, but there's no "pro dialogue" as per say....not at least that I've came across...
A more basic question (one that few screenwriters in here can answer): What is dialog?
A dialogue is a conversation or discussion according to Google. We can think of dialogue (in films) as "A verbal communication (supported by non-verbal communication) between two or more characters trying to agree or disagree on something". If we want to achieve the 'pro' level, non-verbal part is important. In the example above, probably the short dialogue was possible because the screenwriter depends on visual elements or relied on actor's tone and expression. So instead of writing a lengthy dialogue describing everything, he let those other things to speak. Just what I felt.
1 person likes this
Dialog generally is the words in a story spoken by the characters. It should move the story, reveal characters, and cleverly hide exposition.
I don't see any qualitative difference between your remark about the purpose of dialogue and Dan's.
1 person likes this
David Mamet preaches the best movies dont need dialogue to tell the story! Crazy statement from a dude known for dialogue... but hey, who here can rival Mamet?
4 people like this
I remember our first course in film school was called Visual Storytelling - and the first 8 films we made could not have any dialogue, Voice Over, etc. It was such a valuable lesson on 'show don't say'.
2 people like this
Novels are different than SCREENwriting.