Over the years I’ve read a lot of scripts and worked with writers at different stages of their careers, and I’ve noticed that experienced writers tend to approach feedback a little differently.
A few patterns I often see:
1. They leave their ego at the door
It’s natural to feel protective of your work, but the strongest writers focus less on defending the draft and more on improving the story. There’s usually an understanding that the best idea wins, wherever it comes from.
2. They look for the note under the note
Sometimes feedback isn’t the solution, it’s a symptom.
If someone says “this scene feels slow”, the real issue might be that the character’s objective isn’t clear, the stakes aren’t strong enough, or the conflict isn’t landing.
Strong writers try to identify the problem underneath the note rather than taking every suggestion literally.
3. They let their voice shine through
Taking notes doesn’t mean losing what makes your writing distinctive. The best writers absorb feedback, but the final draft still feels unmistakably like them.
4. They rewrite boldly
Professional writers aren’t afraid to rethink scenes, restructure acts, or cut things they love if it strengthens the story. Sometimes you really do have to kill your darlings. The goal isn’t protecting the draft, it’s making the script work.
5. They treat development as collaboration
Often my role as a script editor is to help identify where something isn’t quite working dramatically. In other words, I might come with the problems, and the writer comes with the solutions. That back-and-forth is where scripts really start to evolve.
6. They ask questions
The best writers are curious about feedback. They’ll ask things like:
“Where did you start to lose interest?”
“Was the character’s motivation clear?”
“Did the tone feel consistent?”
Those conversations are what turn notes into practical improvements on the page.
Rewriting and collaboration are such a huge part of the craft, and learning how to interpret notes, and turn them into stronger drafts, is a skill in itself.
I’m always curious how other writers approach notes.
What’s the most useful piece of feedback you’ve ever received on a script?
Or the one that bruised your ego a little… but ultimately made the script much better?
1 person likes this
Também sinto, isso é prova de que a história está envolvente, né?
As someone who came up 10+ feature films is the hardest writing phase in my body of work filmography. I'm talking about brainstorming film pitch, round / fully develop characters, writing structures,...
Expand commentAs someone who came up 10+ feature films is the hardest writing phase in my body of work filmography. I'm talking about brainstorming film pitch, round / fully develop characters, writing structures, outlining scenes, scripts, and shotlists. Not to mention that I'm the only solo writer in controlling the the kind of story, tone, and themes without anyone's help.
João Pimentel you're right
Israel Samuel legal em saber que outra pessoa pensa comigo
João Pimentel we are all the same, we think the same, we were made the same.