I saw OH, MARY! in November when I last went to NYC and it was beyond hysterical. I loved it. Hard to argue with that show topping the list. I would have kept STEREOPHONIC on the list myself but that's why we love to discuss these things. Have you seen any Broadway shows or tours this year that you liked? https://deadline.com/gallery/broadway-best-of-2024-2025-preview/cole-esc...
I was in NYC in October and unfortunately couldn't get tickets to Oh! Mary - I wish I could have! I wish I was a bit closer so I could go and see more off-Broadway shows too, though I did absolutely love the "Twenty Sided Tavern" D&D improv show :)