Screenwriting : Is it good/bad for a screenwriter to blow his/her trumpet??? by Conrad Ekeke

In my experience you should let the writing speak for itself, but you shouldn't feel shy about promoting it. You don't want to query by saying, "this is a hilarious comedy!" They will be turned off by that, trust me. Promote your work, but let it do the horn-tooting.

I better be a pretty good trumpet player if I'm trying to sell something to high-level producers or anyone else. The first trumpets were used to signal war or were used for religious ceremonies. Trying to sell a script is defintely a battle and a war...selling a script/getting contracted to write a script/optioning a script is like a religious experience - at least to me.

I agree with Michael - be a writer first, tell people you're a writer second. If anyone asks me what I do, I'm not shy about telling them I'm a writer - but I'm not pursuing this career so that I can claim the fancy title of "Writer" with a capital W, you know? That's not what it's about. David Foster Wallace talked at one point about how the last thing he wanted to be was one of those guys who went to fancy parties, stood around with a stiff drink, and got to tell people "I'm a writer, I'm a writer." There's no need to be bashful about who you are or what you do, but I think there'll always come a point where the work needs to speak for itself - and if you've spent all your time trumpeting yourself instead of actually writing...well.

Michael, Matthew, Bill, I totally agree with y'all. It's more of a waring situation Bill and yes Michael, you better be right about the trumpet and let it speak for itself. :)

Excellent, excellent post, Matt!

Got a good laugh out of that, Dan...A knowing laugh, but a good laugh.

The work absolutely needs to speak for itself. Horn tooting is rather boring and obvious—not in a good way! Lol! Being confident, humble, open and approachable is much better in my opinion. Anyway, I'd much rather talk about the craft. ;)

Yes he does...

Isn't pitching your scripts to people in the business considered "tooting your horn?" If you've ever pitched a script, don't you consider that to be marketing yourself and your script, or are you tooting your Uncle Schmedrick's horn instead? Are you there to find out a producer's favorite restaurant, or are you there to show someone your goods - your script and yourself? Or having a profile on a website like Stage32, and calling oneself a screenwriter...maybe listing one's screenplay competition placements...listing one's loglines and scripts....and maybe even having your own website, like a lot of screenwriters have - isn't that a big loud toot-toot-toot, too? Maybe some of you don't consider that "tooting your horn"....I sure do. It's marketing, pure and simple, and all writers need to be able to market themselves and their works. It's not like you're required by law to do any of what you all are already doing (even though some of you don't seem to think you are all already doing it) .

Everybody's done it at least once. Talk about something you've done, and after you hit 'send' you're like, "Oh my God, I seem like a horn tooten braggart now!" Maybe you take the bait of one of these guys (present company excluded) who post some really poignant statement or question, and you try to start a conversation, ask them a question and you get no response- making you feel like "Maybe I shouldn't have passionately described my project or something?". Damned if you do , Damned if you don't. But you can't take offense, they probably didn't mean anything by it- just stuff flying by on their cell phone- we forget sometimes that real people are on the other end.

To "toot one's own horn" is an idiomatic phrase which means to promote oneself; to boast or brag; to tout oneself. There's a big difference between bragging/boasting about yourself and talking about a project or what you do for a living. Confidence is a good thing, but bragging is a real turn off. ...And let me tell ya, some of the self-promotion I see on a daily basis is down right obnoxious—just saying.

Fine line- Even the act of just telling a little bit about a project some people would call boasting. What about the "Greatest Show on Earth"? that's boasting. Even if it's true.

Conrad, are you waging some war against my every word? This is the second time you've publicly used my words for a thread. The first time you called my comments repulsive. Now this? And thank-you Beth, that is exactly what I have been saying. Not that anyone pays the least attention to what I am actually saying.

Cherie - I pay attention to your posts. Beth - I hear you. His words are a bit mixed, though, and I concluded the "spirit" of what he was saying when I read the line "and some screenwriters prefer to sell their goods by staying quiet." Maybe I was wrong. But I know in certain situations that I've been in, I have definitely been put in positions to toot my own horn. When I was contracted to write a script, I wasn't the only writer in contention, and had to answer the question "why should we pick you?" Same thing when I optioned a script. Same thing for when I co-founded a newspaper. Same thing for when I wrote ads for political candidates. All my other jobs, too...the last question is always, "why should we choose you?" I doubt I'm the only person who ever had to toot, but when I have to.....I TOOT. I'm sure you can understand that. Maybe his original question would have been more clear in a better context.

"The Greatest Show On Earth" is the title for a film about the Ringling Brothers and the Barnum & Bailey Circus. Perhaps it's even a tagline? Anyway, that's not tooting any one person's horn, that's marketing. Lol!

Bill, in my mind, that's not "tooting your horn" or bragging, that's simply talking about your abilities as a professional; what you bring to the table. Tooting = Bragging. Again, very different. ;)

Yes, be wary of the idiomatic phrase or aphorism! Be sure you are using them clearly and correctly. LOL!

Some people can brag up a storm and they come off just fine, others do it and they come off like jerks. I think that's why a lot of artists seek an agent to sell their product. An agent can 'brag' about the person's work for them, and because they're not as emotionally attached to it they don't come off as needy or desperate for attention. But even to get an agent to believe in it an artist, the artist has to make the pitch to him or her. For example, my agent will probably start like this when he's pitching my show- " I tell you - This is the GREATEST SHOW ON EARTH! " ha ha

Oh, and Cherie, I pay attention! ;)

Am I missing something?

I don't know if that's a good thing or not Beth. ;)

Haha! No, no. It's a good thing. Lol!

Sharing accomplishments are great when expressed in a way that encourages others that they too can achieve a similar goal.

I think it's good to talk about how great you are once you've sold a few things that are well known, but it also might get old fast.

Mark, well said. I think people more than anything just want to tell their stories- so many story tellers, not enough listeners sometimes. But, that's just because everyone is busy.

If you have accomplished something, spread the word. If you are bragging about things that haven't happened, wait until they happen (or you'll look like a pre-bragger and a fraud).

Cherie, no I've not noticed you being repulsive towards me and no, there's nothing about your words used on other posts that I find particular. Though, I apologize for making you feel this way for it must have been a coincidence, trust me it is. However, if this is a subject you can share your views on, and make firm points I think it would help.

Don't just blow it, make music.

Hey everyone, I didn't respond to threads directly because it was important for every opinion to come up fresh and if there's anything anyone has learned from these numerous comments, I think it's worth sharing. However, we can't change the philosophies others have built for themselves because we can make stronger points or bring out the good in everything that's wrong. On this topic, my humble opinion is courage and humility. Those two can blow - toot that flute/horn better. It will permit you watch your steps, it will guide you to and through a just course. Selling a script is just one thing and who is buying it is another. I have sold a script to a buyer who never paid me a cent! I blew my horn, he heard it and liked my melody and came. I was excited, I trusted but then... I regret that today and there's nothing I can do about that. To you who thinks people tell their stories here to brag or something that will directly relate to "tooting one's horn", my word to you is that it's never so. Every story is worth telling and as writers that you are, you must learn to appreciate that and see what intrigues you about the story than the teller. It's not an advice, it's my humble opinion :)

Hahahah Sarah, music will be bragging but if you must, your music must be best. :)

Feed back is the only way to get better.

...Just let your work speak for itself. No horns are necessary. Lol! ;)

Dan, what if you have been unable to make any accomplishments so far but that an opportunity presents for you to prove you can do it? Probably after comparing your work with several others and grading yourself as being a good fit. Will it be advisable to just direct them to read your work? Or if you throw more light on what you're capable of, would it be seen as "tooting your horn"? I think doing both is okay. In a humble manner though. What do you think?

In art and design that I have done professionally for a while, I always say 'the proof is in the pudding.' In an ideal world, a creative meritocracy, the work would stand, and sell, on its own merits. As artists this is important for us that the work can stand on its own legs. Over time I have softened my view and am less averse to explaining or introducing a work to an audience. Providing a context, a motivation, and sometimes an explanation can help bring a work toward a person and help them appreciate it. Be your own toughest critic, and if the work pleases you, don't be afraid to sing its praises.

Bravo John, I like your idea about this.

Thanks Conrad!

Okay, thanks a lot Dan. That's very true and I think it's an easier way to toot :) lol

Write, write, write and watch as your written work improves, it has to, then, you will see how much your work zDhas improved, you will see your voice coming through and hopefully realize what kind of writer you are. Just my humble opinion. Now if I may blow my trumpet? I've completed, magic seven screenplays. Nine is my goal by years end. BETH: How about another November Write Challenge, to push me and everyone along?? So we can ALL unite and blow our trumpets at once?

Hahaha haha... This trumpet thing... Lol

Maybe we can eat some crumpets after we blow our trumpets?

You're "rhymist" too :) love the that crumpets & trumpets. Sure, if we don't blow the trumpets off like... BOOM! Lol

Jorge, yes, I'm sure we could do another Write Club challenge, but at the moment life is a bit hectic. We'll have to come back to that at a later time; talk to the powers that be. Lol! :)

November is still far away, Beth. We'll come back to the subject, then.

I can only speak for myself as a producer. If you are asked about your qualifications, I think you must state them objectively in order to properly introduce yourself and to clearly convey your credentials. You should be allowed to take credit for what you've worked hard to achieve. For example, "What are my qualifications? I sold a pilot to HBO in a 4-network competitive situation. I'm so privileged to be working with this proven showrunner. May I tell you about some of my other projects?" Those are objective facts about something I worked hard to achieve. I do not think the optics are as good if you state your qualifications subjectively. For example, "What are my qualifications? I'm a great producer because I sold an awesome pilot to HBO." That's a subjective opinion. But as we all know, people have different styles and being vocal really, really works for some people. Just look at Donald Trump. Many people are buying his claims. So if it's working for Trump to brag, then he has no reason to change his style. There's also the new-ish term "humble-brag" which is all over social media, right? :-)

Yes Regina. That sounds wonderful. Thank you

Hahahah and Trump is doing the humble bragging. Lol :)

I really believe that some people are gifted with great charisma and interpersonal skills, and if they brag, people love it. I am not that lucky! If I brag, people want to throw tomatoes at me. :-)

That makes the two of us ;)

Self-taught hack! Sounds "trumpety"... Hey, I'm kidding Dan, I love the sound of that and it's how a true writer should express him/herself. I guess we're buying it, all of us. :D

What Matt and Dan said! :D

When a creative doesn't need to tell me how good they are, that's when I know they're good.

True Brian.

When a creative can write something that can only come from them. When they are courageous enough to search for stories to which they have a real personal connection, that's when I know they're good. Agreed, Brian? Come on, say yes, brother.

Yes Jorge. Very true and I've experienced what you say. Fiona, I think that's a good strategy that can get us the attention we most times want but it's true that it's not easy but we must not also give up.

Jorge and Conrad... agreed. I think the main thing is to express ourselves in a way which expresses our Unique Voice while expressing the tale we hope to tell... with our own unique 'flavor'

Brian, that's an advice I wouldn't neglect ever. It's a summary of everything that makes a true writer and we hope we all work in that path as you've put it. Thanks man :D