Hi everyone! I'd love to hear what everyone is working on (or recently finished.)
Hi everyone! I'd love to hear what everyone is working on (or recently finished.)
Hi everyone! Happy Wednesday . . . (I'm pretty sure it's Wednesday) . . . I remember my first composition really well, where I was in life, what inspired it, and the amazing feeling when it was done since, before that, I never thought I could compose. Do you remember your first creation?
I took my first class "music fundamentals" in the summer of 2003. Before then I knew nothing formally about music and music notation. SO I was playing around with my DAW at the time (Sonar) and a samp...
Expand commentI took my first class "music fundamentals" in the summer of 2003. Before then I knew nothing formally about music and music notation. SO I was playing around with my DAW at the time (Sonar) and a sampler called Gigastudio. I had just acquired an orchestra suite known as "Moroslav". So my first piece had no reverb and was not aligned or clicktracked and was a bunch of experimental sections. It remains my benchmark of how far I have come since 2003:
The issue for me is the same as sort of when someone uses the word 'aspiring' - either you are or your not? I posted on this topic here a few months back and tried to differentiate the two by whether...
Expand commentThe issue for me is the same as sort of when someone uses the word 'aspiring' - either you are or your not? I posted on this topic here a few months back and tried to differentiate the two by whether you get paid or not. But I'm not even sure of that anymore. Perhaps pay is associated with the word 'job'. And perhaps 'career' is associated with 'passion'. Be that it may, I am not sure whether my pursuit is rightly called a hobby or career. As I have scored 35 films the last 12 years and have been paid for for one - you tell me. And it took 25 years for my ASCAP royalties to make it to $14.55 - so what is my songwriting - career or hobby? I guess for me the bottom line is that the decision is sort of 'mute' - sort of whether I am or have been 'aspiring' or not.
That's awesome, Mark Gosney! I think that path is a great one, because I, like you, don't ever want the pressure to HAVE to create something. I'm a rebel, so you can imagine what happens when you tell...
Expand commentThat's awesome, Mark Gosney! I think that path is a great one, because I, like you, don't ever want the pressure to HAVE to create something. I'm a rebel, so you can imagine what happens when you tell me to do something. I think it's wonderful to have a part-time or full-time job (that you enjoy) that still allows time for creation. Best balance in my opinion.
That is a very good point Joel Irwin. It all depends on your mindset, perspective, and priorities. I do think for the purpose of my question, the difference between hobby and career had more to do wit...
Expand commentThat is a very good point Joel Irwin. It all depends on your mindset, perspective, and priorities. I do think for the purpose of my question, the difference between hobby and career had more to do with whether it paid your way, or if it (on taxes) was still considered a hobby. In our hearts, I think no matter what the monetary compensation is, our creations are our passions. And hobbies are often thought of as our passions. It's nice when we can make ends meet with our passions, but then there is the slippery slope of the pressure to do so. It's the biggest reason I didn't pursue a music career when I was thinking about jobs. I never wanted to lose my joy for it. And scoring 35 films?! That's pretty cool :)
I have a track which has been fully arranged and scored electronically with samples. Got a lyricist to write words. I thought this would be a great opportunity to try a samples-based virtual vocal to compare it against another track I am currently creating a demo with a live singer this coming tue...
Expand postI have a track which has been fully arranged and scored electronically with samples. Got a lyricist to write words. I thought this would be a great opportunity to try a samples-based virtual vocal to compare it against another track I am currently creating a demo with a live singer this coming tues.
Looking at what is on the market and will be one to try. Seems to me with a fully scored track and words, that Acestudio (and not Suno) would be an opportune one. Anyone have experience and/or opinions with Acestudio? I am NOT in this post looking to discuss legalities or other non-technical opinions. That would make for a great separate post here. For this post I am looking at a vocalist much the same as I have been looking at virtual instrumentation for the last 30 years - another vocal entity that creates sound based on my notes, articulations and words.
Got experience or opinions? Speak! :)
Here is my website: www.thevoiceofleeloo.com. I am currently looking for work on any compositions that have the potential to get placed in TV or film.
I will wait for you to accept my request so I can...
Expand commentHere is my website: www.thevoiceofleeloo.com. I am currently looking for work on any compositions that have the potential to get placed in TV or film.
I will wait for you to accept my request so I can send you a message :)
I haven't used it, but my friend Leo did an amazing demo with it. When you don't have access to singers and little or no budget with high expectations I can sure see where it'd be a welcomed piece of...
Expand commentI haven't used it, but my friend Leo did an amazing demo with it. When you don't have access to singers and little or no budget with high expectations I can sure see where it'd be a welcomed piece of software to master. Of course it would be easier, better, faster, more fun with singers in the studio.
This is what I used to hear say 25 years about Gigastudio orchestral samples, "when you don't have access to instruments and little to no budget with high expectations...."
As another year has started and I have 'note to self' to check, I believe I asked/discussed last year my disappointment after using Sibelius since 2003 that it did not support VST3 (and hence I can not use VST libraries with Kontakt 7/8). As I recollect last year I tried a 'hack' that allowed me to...
Expand postAs another year has started and I have 'note to self' to check, I believe I asked/discussed last year my disappointment after using Sibelius since 2003 that it did not support VST3 (and hence I can not use VST libraries with Kontakt 7/8). As I recollect last year I tried a 'hack' that allowed me to support VST3 but I had trouble using VST3 and VST2 libraries / instruments at the same time. So I have decided that the hack is not a solution for me.
So I have not found anything so far to tell me that SIbelius now supports VST3 so unless someone can say otherwise, I am still led to the conclusion that Sibelius does not natively support VST3.
I have been holding off for years using SIbelius with VST2 only because of my 20 year investment in scores/files. But without VST3 support, I am probably going to move to Dorico this year under the assumption that I can use both VST2 and VST3 libraries with Kontakt 7/8. If not possible, I gues I can use Sibelius for VST2 and Dorico with VST3.
What's the current scoop with Sibelius and VST3?
I know what you mean. I spent $5.6k on a Mac Studio two weeks ago. Before that I was working on an intel iMac that I paid maybe $2.7k for and it worked perfectly for 5 years doing this stuff. It ran S...
Expand commentI know what you mean. I spent $5.6k on a Mac Studio two weeks ago. Before that I was working on an intel iMac that I paid maybe $2.7k for and it worked perfectly for 5 years doing this stuff. It ran Sibelius, Dorico, Digital Performer, all the VSL and Spitfire stuff, and Kontakt 8 all day long. You don't have to jump ship. You'd just add to the fleet.....and you're worth it! Credit card that muv! lol
This is what I found out from a search now on Dorico - VST 2.
https://helpcenter.steinberg.de/hc/en-us/articles/206899770-How-to-use-V......
Expand commentThis is what I found out from a search now on Dorico - VST 2.
https://helpcenter.steinberg.de/hc/en-us/articles/206899770-How-to-use-V...
I' not really using Sib. 7.5 anymore; I made the leap at beg. of the Dorico announcement, and I'm able to use NI 11 +, and other 3rd party software: Enbertone strings, and Spitfire programs. Wow, lear...
Expand commentI' not really using Sib. 7.5 anymore; I made the leap at beg. of the Dorico announcement, and I'm able to use NI 11 +, and other 3rd party software: Enbertone strings, and Spitfire programs. Wow, learning the SoundPaint interface is quite interesting for sure. I'm not answering your questions, .. only my experiences.
From my above link, looks like there are ways to use VST 2 sounds. Do a little more homework.. I'm off a Zoom call with a new short movie. ... Yea !! Lots of work for this short.
Here is one definition of a hobby: "A hobby is a pastime or leisure activity conducted in your spare time for recreation or pleasure."
Here is another possible definition from webster: "a pursuit outside one's regular occupation engaged in especially for relaxation"
Or perhaps this one: "what defines...
Expand postHere is one definition of a hobby: "A hobby is a pastime or leisure activity conducted in your spare time for recreation or pleasure."
Here is another possible definition from webster: "a pursuit outside one's regular occupation engaged in especially for relaxation"
Or perhaps this one: "what defines a hobby? A hobby is any activity that a person pursues because they enjoy it and with no intention of making a profit."
And from the anals of the IRS:
https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/heres-how-to-tell-the-difference-between-a-....So as a composer or musician, are you doing it as a hobby or a business? And if you are creating or performing music without any intent of making money (or a profit), is it a hobby or a business.
And to complicate things, let's add the word 'retirement'. If you retire from a primary profession which is not music and now you are film composer or musician - are you doing it as a hobby or business? Or perhaps your being 'retired' has no impact on your status as a hobbyist or businessman.
So you may ask, "Who cares what you call it". Here are perhaps at least two reasons:
1. Perhaps (maybe not), if a filmmaker is considering hiring you to score and learns that you score for free or significantly reduced cost, that you may not be serious about the composing profession. They may judge you as a hobbyist who is seriously less qualified than a composing professional who gets paid.
2. In the U.S. (and perhaps other countries), you need to declare your 'intent' with the taxing authorities - if it is a business, you will need to agree to and adhere to a set of operating rules (especially if you don't work alone).
I have scored 35 films and 'retired' from my previous profession (my doctoral work was in Technology - Artificial Intelligence back in the 1970s) in 2003. I have only been paid for one film. I consider myself a composing professional for the last 21 years (not retired, not a hobbyist) and I have filed my composing as a business on my tax returns each year.
Hence the LLC I set up a few years ago! :~). www.kerrykennard.com - I have two gigs this weekend and had a friend / client pay for the percussion recording this week. First inquiry for Conga lessons c...
Expand commentHence the LLC I set up a few years ago! :~). www.kerrykennard.com - I have two gigs this weekend and had a friend / client pay for the percussion recording this week. First inquiry for Conga lessons came through the updated website this morning. No Hobby here!
Business can be such a creative journey, right? Just like in this artwork, it’s all about finding those unique opportunities and looking at things from a fresh angle. Real estate, for example, isn’t j...
Expand commentBusiness can be such a creative journey, right? Just like in this artwork, it’s all about finding those unique opportunities and looking at things from a fresh angle. Real estate, for example, isn’t just about buying properties; it’s about exploring markets that are really on the rise. I actually started looking into real estate abroad and stumbled upon some great options in the Philippines https://mlsworldwide.com/en/sale-venezuela had listings that opened my eyes to the potential there. Sometimes, stepping outside the usual places can bring really cool investment ideas you might not have thought of!
Perhaps if you're somewhere in between you could call it a career
MakeMusic ends development and availability of Finale; partners with Steinberg to sell Dorico directly.
https://www.scoringnotes.com/news/makemusic-ends-development-and-availab......
Expand postMakeMusic ends development and availability of Finale; partners with Steinberg to sell Dorico directly.
https://www.scoringnotes.com/news/makemusic-ends-development-and-availab...
I’m really liking Dorico. I watched several tutorials. Some from them and I grabbed the Groove 3 and Udemy courses. I did my first arr using Dorico this week and it went pretty smooth. Took me longer...
Expand commentI’m really liking Dorico. I watched several tutorials. Some from them and I grabbed the Groove 3 and Udemy courses. I did my first arr using Dorico this week and it went pretty smooth. Took me longer than if I’d used Sibelius because I don’t have the key commands memorized yet. So things that I wanted to do I’d have to google or refer to the vids again, but I’m happy with the experience of it. One thing that got me right off the bat was working in the full score and then hitting “w” to look at parts. The parts from jump looked pretty darn good. Sure, if I was handing them out to players there was tweaking to do, but I printed them all out so I could play it in and I didn’t tweak anything and it was great for that. I can see that I can prepare charts much faster than usual. Plus the stock samples are better sounding to me. I have Note Performer, but haven’t tried it yet in Dorico. Glad I made the purchase. :)
Linwood Bell - try the drop down for each different part.
Yes, Dorico seems faster and cleaner / has less hit problems than Sibelius 7.5.
W - huh ? Hmm have not heard about this Key command for Showin...
Expand commentLinwood Bell - try the drop down for each different part.
Yes, Dorico seems faster and cleaner / has less hit problems than Sibelius 7.5.
W - huh ? Hmm have not heard about this Key command for Showing parts. I usually use the Drop down menu to go to each instrument.
The version 5.1 manual is always helpful as well.
You can find the manual from Steinberg, I doing a Google search on it. I have it - if you need a copy.
Can I email it to you ?
Yes, some of Dorico’s HALion sounds are really nice! One of the Sax sounds has the real nice flutter nuances as well as the slide effect between notes. There’s the actual noise too - adjustable to your liking.
Thanks...I've got it all. :) The "w" key command was used in Sibelius for parts as well. I've still got an active Sibelius license for almost another year. I've got 20 years worth of "stuff" written i...
Expand commentThanks...I've got it all. :) The "w" key command was used in Sibelius for parts as well. I've still got an active Sibelius license for almost another year. I've got 20 years worth of "stuff" written in it that I need to deal with. I'll batch export to xml and be done with it. Lotta stuff to organize in the next few months and no joy in doing it.
Here's what I did in Dorico, btw. I played rhodes, bass, and drums in digital performer along with the vocal. ( That's my friend, Elisa. She was a bg singer for Prince.) Then I exported that midi to Dorico and wrote the chart there. Then printed it all out and played those parts back into DP and bingo. In Sibelius I use to be able to just bounce an mp3 and import that into Sibelius and write against it and that way I could hear the vocal as you're writing the chart. I don't think you can do that in Dorico (?) I tried, but couldn't figure it out. In .sib you just import it like you would a movie and it worked. It's a nice touch. https://www.linwoodbell.com/clientdownloads/Love%20Dance.mp3
I recently participated in my 11th year of scoring a film for the 168 film festival in Atlanta last weekend. I scored a film called "The Offer'. I was also asked to score a second film called, "Counted" but the film was still being worked on the night before the deadline and never locked and so I...
Expand postI recently participated in my 11th year of scoring a film for the 168 film festival in Atlanta last weekend. I scored a film called "The Offer'. I was also asked to score a second film called, "Counted" but the film was still being worked on the night before the deadline and never locked and so I ended up not scoring it. Instead, the filmmaker/producer wrote a song, sung it in a studio and had it formally produced. Then in addition to using the song intact, the editor used parts of the song scattered throughout the film.
There were 45 film entries. My score was not nominated. Not only was the music for "Counted" nominated, but "Counted" won multiple awards (not score) including best film at the festival.
That was story 1. Now last year (same festival), I scored a film called "Flatline". The film was fully scored the night before with the film totally locked. Then sometime late the night before the deadline they unlocked the film and redid multiple scenes. My stated policy going into the gig was that I would not release the music as a single WAV file until the final score was approved and used as is (and not broken into parts). As a result I apparently angered the director who decided to release/submit the film without any music in it.
The agreements/contracts for the films for the 168 festival are not 'work for hire' and do not grant the filmmakers the rights to do whatever they want with the music. These are shorts that are scored for free and are not features. My views then and still is that if it is not a work for hire and I am scoring for free, I retain ownership of the music and once the filmmaker approves the music, I can ask the editor to place the music (which is a single wav file) on a separate track starting at 0m0s. If it is a work for hire and I am being paid, then they are welcome to include any clause they want in the contract including their right if they so choose, to use parts of the score anywhere they want in the film.
I can see both sides of this issue. But I currently feel that if I am asked to score to their spec (typically a cuesheet with cues some of which have temp tracks) and am approved doing so, then the filmmaker has a level of trust in my professionalism and artistry that I know how to create the proper cues in the correct places in the film.
Both approaches in my opinion are legitimate. Of the 40 some odd films I have scored (35 of which released), only 2 were not because either (1) I would not let the music be used in parts or (2) I would not release a WAV file of the score until the film was locked and the full score was reviewed and approved.
Does the Director write the work for Hire most of the time, Joel ?
I read the first one is Atlanta. Are you close to this area ? I heard Atlanta has a good film industry.
I’m in Ohio and there’s a few...
Expand commentDoes the Director write the work for Hire most of the time, Joel ?
I read the first one is Atlanta. Are you close to this area ? I heard Atlanta has a good film industry.
I’m in Ohio and there’s a few things going on.
In Dublin / Columbus area there’s a new Studio for film/ Hollywood style production supposedly going up and being built.
Thanks for the story / info. to help us in our Composing careers. KK
A couple of days ago, I heard a talk by an established and experienced composer, Carlos Rivera who has won 3 prime time emmys whose scores include Queens Gambit and Hacks. He talks about being asked to score a 20 second clip and provided with a temp track (which by the way came from the opening of...
Expand postA couple of days ago, I heard a talk by an established and experienced composer, Carlos Rivera who has won 3 prime time emmys whose scores include Queens Gambit and Hacks. He talks about being asked to score a 20 second clip and provided with a temp track (which by the way came from the opening of the "Caravan" track from Whiplash). He (and his co-composer) had some ideas as to how the clip should be scored and jazz was not his strong suit. They ended up going through something like 17 rejected cues until they finally scored a cue which had a jazzy rhythm and horns (which sounded pretty close to the temp track). His recommendations is score the way you are asked and if you want have an alternate track in your back pocket to offer though be prepared to not have it selected.
By the way, I was amazed how much time two rather well established studio composers spent on a single 20 second cue on a TV series.
I am a solely a composer. I am not a screenwriter, producer, director, etc. None of those jobs have any interest to me. And as such, I am disappointed that there does not seem to be anyway in the advanced world of "AI" where software can analyze my interests for me to get targeted emails from sta...
Expand postI am a solely a composer. I am not a screenwriter, producer, director, etc. None of those jobs have any interest to me. And as such, I am disappointed that there does not seem to be anyway in the advanced world of "AI" where software can analyze my interests for me to get targeted emails from stage32 that I am interested in. I continue to get a very large number of emails from stage32 especially script related stuff which I need to spend time to look at and delete. I want to get emails from stage32 that I care about - music related blogs, classes, and other audio related material. I don't want the 20 or so emails I get a day from stage32 that have nothing to do with my profession.
I have been suggesting a tailored/targeted email approach to support for a few months now but they just don't get it.
Here is an idea. Let me respond to an email whether I want to get more like it in the future or not. So if I say no to a script one, then no more script ones - especially if I am not a member of that lounge.
P.S. - would have put this post in the support lounge but there isn't one.
If you want to see what classes there are for composers, go to the education tab and search by topic. That was recently updated to make finding specific topics easier.
My overall point is/was that he emails are all or nothing - everybody gets everything without any regard to interests. On your last comment for example, I can choose only to get emails on all educatio...
Expand commentMy overall point is/was that he emails are all or nothing - everybody gets everything without any regard to interests. On your last comment for example, I can choose only to get emails on all educational opportunities - not just the ones of interest to composers.
I have been stage32 participant for well over 10 years and honor you for your choice to help out. However, the current support paradigm is not particularly effective. Though I agree with you that nothing is unlikely to change with the current coding model. For example, I have complained for over 5 years how difficult it is to edit an original post in a lounge or that you can attach pictures but not pdf's (which is how us composers share and discuss scores).
I just went ahead and turned everything off. shame - but too many irrelevant emails for me.
P.S. - this post was originally in the composing lounge. I am not sure why it was moved to acting but am a sure there is a legitimate explanation :)
Joel Irwin On editing. Hi John, you can go to the down arrow ^ at the top right of your post and click on it. There are lots of options there and one includes EDIT
Merely an 'observation'.
I was at a meeting last night of the local chapter of the Nashville Songwriters Association ( https://www.nashvillesongwriters.com ). I was playing a music only demo song for a potential lyricist collaborator. As it was a potential duet - I created a demo with a flute for t...
Expand postMerely an 'observation'.
I was at a meeting last night of the local chapter of the Nashville Songwriters Association ( https://www.nashvillesongwriters.com ). I was playing a music only demo song for a potential lyricist collaborator. As it was a potential duet - I created a demo with a flute for the female and clarinet for the male.
I received a reaction that has been very typical of listeners (even musically trained ones) that are outside the 'scoring world' - they get quite surprised when I say that nothing on the track was live or for completed demos, that the only live entity was the singer.
I find that to be true regardless of how 'realistic' the sample set is implemented - even if my scoring friends tell me that the reproduction is of less than 'stellar' quality.
Point is, when I (and perhaps 'we') implement a sampled configuration, the basic 'sound' is close enough imho to 'real' that the 'average' listener normally can't tell the difference between sample and real.
BTW - here is what I played last night:
Hi Joel, will there be a singer on the tune, Pooh ?
Flute does sound fairly real, … maybe make a little warmer sounding - if possible.
I used to EQ on some of my tracks; one is from logic Pro, and the...
Expand commentHi Joel, will there be a singer on the tune, Pooh ?
Flute does sound fairly real, … maybe make a little warmer sounding - if possible.
I used to EQ on some of my tracks; one is from logic Pro, and the other is from native instruments. Sometimes it helps and sometimes it doesn’t., so I’ll turn one off, making sure it sounds more natura.
One small suggestion, .. is it possible to end at the 2:40 mark ? Thr other last bars seems a repeat of previous and to the IV chord right ? - before the end ?
It is something I learned recently, keeping it shorter and ending with the A section.
- from Michele Maslin
Otherwise, it’s a more piece !!
Keep submitting!
Kerry Kennard
When I create this type of file there is no intent for it to be considered a production file. I call it more of a manifestation file - it give the lyricist one way (in addition to the lead sheet with...
Expand commentWhen I create this type of file there is no intent for it to be considered a production file. I call it more of a manifestation file - it give the lyricist one way (in addition to the lead sheet with melody and chords), for the lyricist to 'imagine' the tune in order to lay down lyrics. I spend no time to 'fine tune' the piece. I picked flute for female and clarinet for male merely as place markers. On my previous collaboration, the imagined file I sent was not used at all. The melody was changed to accommodate the lyrics and the lyricist both sung and totally produced it herself in her studio. My total involvement was the melody and suggestions for chords and arrangements. When I collaborate on a song, I often find the track produced is many times 'better' in my judgement than anything I could have arranged and produced myself (as was the case in "In Can").
Check out the previous song I collaborated on: https://www.soundcloud.com/joelirwin/i-can
Sounds good, Joel. It’s perfect for giving them a clear idea of how you envision it and then you can work on it together later and tweak if needed. We are lucky that we can use samples and get our ideas out without having to hire anyone.
Award winning Film Composer/Scorer. 35 IMDB credit films - 2 wins and 5 nominations. Over 10 years active in Stage32 composer lounge.
Here is a sample of my most recent score:
I also collaborate as a songwriter. Here is a childrens song I co-wrote with Ange...
Expand postAward winning Film Composer/Scorer. 35 IMDB credit films - 2 wins and 5 nominations. Over 10 years active in Stage32 composer lounge.
Here is a sample of my most recent score:
https://on.soundcloud.com/xE2xkCj3rtVkV3iH9
I also collaborate as a songwriter. Here is a childrens song I co-wrote with Angela Parish (lyrics and singer) who is known as the lead singer of the opening bridge scene in "La La Land" (Another Day Of Sun).
https://www.soundcloud.com/joelirwin/i-can
My Music : https://soundcloud.com/joelirwin
My IMDB:
https://www.imdb.com/name/nm5688919
I write both live and electronic / sampled music for both instrumental and vocal performances. I write in multiple genres including film/tv scores/themes/cues, classical, jazz, pop, adult contemporary and Christmas. I also score live jazz pieces and arrangements of small Jazz ensembles up to full Jazz big bands
Hey, Joel Irwin. Hope you're doing great. What's your favorite genre to write in?
I love written lead sheets and big band charts and get to hear them played and improvised live.
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. By using this site, you are accepting our cookie policy
1 person likes this
James Wunderlich Thank you!!! I appreciate that so much!
1 person likes this
Gian Carlo Feoli Listening now! It's beautiful and so powerful. Wonderful job!
1 person likes this
You're welcome